|
|
Part I of Programmatic Spanish consists
of 210 pages of text and 3 hours and 13 minutes of audio. Part II has
286 pages of text, and 3 hours and 52 minutes of audio. Total 496 pages
of text, and a little over 7 hours of audio. Download size: Part I 237.8
MB, Part II 186.7 MB. Total 426.5 MB. I am in the process of
appropriately illustrating the course, which will increase the file
sizes somewhat, but will take a while.
The following was taken almost verbatim
from a posting in How-to-learn-any-language.com. (This is a wonderful
resource for advice and discussion by experienced language learners, and
I highly recommend it.)
Many people consider Programmatic
Spanish (PM) an excellent accompaniment to Platiquemos. Programmatic
Spanish was never completed (it was supposed to have 100 lessons, but
only has 50. Many dealers sell PM as the first to volumes, and then sell
the original Basic Course (unedited and not modernized or optimized for
use without the book) 3 and 4 as follow-ons. This is a very bad idea,
since the two programs differ radically in method and progression of
structure elements (see below). I have seen PM advertised for as much as
$420, so free is quite a bargain!
I myself used PM for a while at FSI,
and didnīt like it. Different people have different learning styles,
though, and there are many who think it's great--except for it's not
being complete.
I (the poster on
How-to-learn-any-language.com) think both courses are good. When I was
only using the Basic Course in the form of Platiquemos, I
listened to each tape about 14 times over the course of a week. I would
have the material down very well at on the 7th day.
Today, I'm doing both courses simultaneously. However, I only go through
the Platiquemos lessons 7 times over a weeks time, rather than
14. I still feel I understand the material very well by the 7th day. I
do
1 1/2 units from Programmatic
Spanish each week also. I think the
synergism between the courses makes it so I don't have to repeat the
Platiquemos lessons as many times to get them down.
If you cannot sit down with the book,
Programmatic Spanish won't be good
for you. Most of it's exercises require the book. Platiquemos, on
the other hand can be well utilized without the book. The books are
helpful though, and I read the book with the lesson the first time
through. The second day, I read the dialog before I hit the highway to
keep the translation fresh in my mind. One nice thing about
Platiquemos is the dialog translation is part of the recording. It's
still helpful to read the grammatical points too. They are usually very
short.
The two courses cover grammatical points in somewhat different order.
Programmatic
Spanish starts out with the preterit (one of two Spanish past
tenses--[I have no idea why]),whereas Platiquemos uses the more
traditional approach of starting with the present tense. Perhaps I can
do the Platiquemos units with less review because I've been
working on the preterit for weeks with
Programmatic Spanish.
Programmatic
Spanish volume 1 is described as a 100 hour course. Volume 2
takes the typical student 150 hours. So
Programmatic Spanish could be
thought of as a 250 hour course.
Platiquemos is self described as 500-600 hour courses. FSI
expects a typical bright English student to take 575-600 hours or so to
become professionally fluent in a language like
Spanish if it's their first foreign tongue.
If you can only study an hour a day, it's probably better to focus on
only one of the courses. In that case, I'd make my decision based on
whether I like to sit down with a book (or pdf rendition of a book) and
recordings, or whether my schedule doesn't permit that amount of time in
front of a computer or printout of the book.
x
x
x
|
|
|